500 West Live Oak Street
Coleman, Texas

Legal Description:  Phillips 2nd Addition, Block 22, Lots 2, 3, 4 and part of Lot 1


 

There had been Methodist ministers holding services in this wild, western country before 1876. At that time, the Northwest Texas Conference began sending pioneer Methodist ministers to hold religious services when Coleman was established. There were nine charter members when the Methodist Episcopal Church South was organized in Coleman by the Rev. W. C. Brodie in the upper room of the stone building known as the Paddleford building on South Commercial Avenue in 1881. The Methodists bought the 500 block of West Live Oak Street on which the present church stands, and in 1889 under the pastorate of Rev. C. H. Oswalt, built the first church, a frame building with Gothic windows.


part of 1888 map


part of 1893 map

1898 map

There was a small dwelling on the east side of Block 22, north of the location where the Methodist Church was built in 1889 at what became 500 West Live Oak Street.



Methodist Church
in the early 1900s
(taken from an old colored commemorative plate)


Methodist Church in background
about 1915, from the yard of Ben Robey at 416 West Pecan Street





1904 map

1909 map

1916 map
(note tabernacle across the street)

Under the pastorate of Rev. M. K. Little, a liberal subscription was raised and a large brick church building was completed in the summer of 1916 (as seen in the 1916 map). Tiffany art glass windows portrayed Biblical scenes and church leaders and symbols and preserved the memory of early church members.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"In 1929, the First Methodist Church was located on West Live Oak Street and the northwest corner of North Neches Street (now 500 West Live Oak Street)." 
(Coleman City Directory, 1929 - Hudspeth.)


The Second Methodist Church Building
pictured in the 1940s



Interior of First United Methodist Church, 1951



1923 map

1930 map

1948 map


Soon after 1951, with the assignment of the Rev. J. D. F. Williams to the church, the recognition that the church needed a new building to meet the needs of the congregation was made and plans began to be formulated. Ground breaking for the new First United Methodist Church was held on June 9, 1957. The old building was located on the southeast corner of the block and the new sanctuary was built on the southwest corner. Construction began right away. The first service was held on March 31, 1958.


Groundbreaking, 1957


Construction beginning on new building, 1957


New building to left, old building to r
new building to left, old buliding to right, 1958

Old building being razed, 1959

In July 1959, workmen began tearing down the old First Methodist Church building. Some of the materials from the old building were used in the construction of the new fellowship hall and Sunday school class rooms. After the old building was removed, a new fellowship hall was built north of the new sanctuary and a chapel on the site of the old building, with class rooms built between the two buildings.


The Third Methodist Church Building
built in 1958 - picture taken in 1961


In February 1968, Mrs. Ann (Miller) Hargett, became the music director at the First Methodist Church. She had been a member and soloist of the chancel choir and served as co-director from 1956 to 1961. After studying music in college, marrying and beginning a family, she taught voice as well as being a ranch owner with her husband. 

In September 1972, a program and lunch was served, with about 265 attending, to recognize Bobbie Warren, who had served as the official church organist for 50 years, beginning in 1922. The prominent pioneer ranch woman, Mrs. Martha Tye Overall, saw to it that the First Methodist Church had a pipe organ (below left, 1951, with Bobbie Warren at the organ) and she even sent Sarah Murray to Texas Women's College to take instruction in playing the pipe organ. Miss Murray was church organist until 1920 when she married. At that time Girlie Hubert and Bobbie White were taking lessons from Miss Murray. Girlie Hubert followed Miss Murray as organist. By 1921, Bobbie White and John Warren had married, and when Miss Hubert left Mrs. Overall made a special trip to see Bobbie Warren and asked her to become church organist. When the new church was built in 1958, the old pipes from the organ were retained although they were concealed behind a panel, which was behind the illuminated cross.  (below right).


Pipe organ in old building, 1951

Concealed pipe organ in new building, 1963


On the night of September 2, 1998, a fire, determined to have been caused by arson to an old vacant house which was approximately 25 feet north of the church, caused the church to catch on fire, destroying the classrooms, offices and fellowship hall.  Saved from fire were the sanctuary, chapel, and library, which suffered heavy smoke damage.  Stained glass on the north side of the sanctuary appeared to be warped from intense heat.  The walls of the sanctuary were intact.  There was some water damage, but those parts of the church were repaired. 

After rebuilding and repair,
the church had its first service since the fire in January 2001.  An open house followed on June 24, 2001.  The two pictures below were taken by Cliff Horn, a church member.  Cliff took pictures of the progress of rebuilding and put an album together, which I have placed in the Coleman Public Library.



Ruins of house where the fire began, September 3, 1998.


Work on the church completed, January 2001.


First United Methodist Church - March 2003

Church and new classrooms - chapel to right of picture

Chapel


South Side of Auditorium

Church Hall - west side
.....................................................



2023 Aerial view of block

...................................................................

(See additional history and images of the Coleman Methodist Church, see the History of the Coleman Methodist Church.)


 
 
Coleman - Street Index
Coleman County Research Tools
Use the Search Engine to search
the Coleman County website.